banner



20 Degree Pressure Angle Gears

20 degrees vs 14.5 degrees force per unit area angle for gears

All Topics | Latest Posts

Martin Rock-Evans 14/01/2018 20:45:23
26 forum posts
14 photos

Hi,

I'yard looking to brand a set of spur gears for my 3" Burrell. The drawings show these as 10 DP with a 20 caste pressure level bending and betwixt 17 and seventy teeth, however I'm struggling to find an affordable gear up of cutters with a 20 caste pressure angle (£100+ a cutter is non affordable). RDG Tools exercise an affordable set of x DP gear cutters at 14.5 caste pressure bending. How much of a difference would the ii pressure level angles make (understanding that the whole train needs the aforementioned DP and pressure bending) or can anyone recommend a supplier who tin supply x DP gear cutters with 20 degree pressure bending.

Many cheers,

Martin

JasonB fourteen/01/2018 twenty:49:23
avatar
Moderator
23495 forum posts
2852 photos
1 articles

Information technology won't make much deviation and will be closer to the original gear profile equally a bonus and works improve if you lot accept a sprung back axle.

John Hinkley fourteen/01/2018 21:48:48
avatar
1390 forum posts
435 photos

Martin,

If it helps to visualise what Jason has proposed, I attach a portion of a drawing showing a 70 molar 20° PA x DP gear ( the lower gear portion in black ) with a gear portion of the same specification, only 14.5° PA ( in carmine ) superimposed, meshing with a portion of a 17 molar 14.v° PA 10 DP gear ( to a higher place ).

20? v 14.5? gears meshing

Information technology was generated using GearDXF program and manipulated in QCAD Professional.

John

Muzzer fourteen/01/2018 21:52:35
avatar
2904 forum posts
448 photos

The twenty caste PA teeth are more "triangular" (less parallel) than the fourteen.5 and one result is a larger radial forcefulness pushing the gears apart when a given torque is applied. The teeth are also slightly more than robust.

Murray

Brian Forest xv/01/2018 08:42:26
2610 forum posts
39 photos

Martin,

In that location is an alternative and that might be to cutting the gears as a metric set, 2.v Mod and xx caste PA.

The cutters might be more than competitively priced for those and your build notes would record the change from plans for the benefit of someone further downwardly the line.

I'll at present retreat to the defended bunker

Brian

Brian Wood fifteen/01/2018 09:31:53
2610 forum posts
39 photos

Martin,

Perhaps I should add that if you go downwards the metric route yous will need to make adjustments to reduce the centre to heart distances between the shafts accordingly from those shown on the drawing. They are not big, but would be important.

Brian

Muzzer 15/01/2018 12:03:36
avatar
2904 forum posts
448 photos

You can of course choose any module size you care to define, non simply nice round numbers. You lot wouldn't be able to buy an off the shelf cutter for that exact size mayhap but for the purposes of making a functioning calibration model, you could surely use the nearest "standard" size which may be just marginally different. That style you wouldn't need to mess with the centre distances.

To calculate your custom module size, yous'd dissever the reference diameter by the number of teeth. If there is a std module size close to that, you tin take a view on whether it is close enough not to worry near.

Every bit an example, I recently specified some gears in a mixture of modern sizes including 0.98. As the mould was going to be particularly made anyway, it was no skin off anyone's teeth if they didn't all come out as verbal integers.

Murray

Edited By Muzzer on 15/01/2018 12:07:45

HOWARDT xv/01/2018 13:54:20
965 forum posts
39 photos

You can make a gear abnormal or subnormal, ie the PCD is slightly more or less than normal for a given module or diametral pitch. I often used gears like this were gear centres were stock-still for any reason. Information technology does give a weaker root to the tooth when subnormal. Ideally you lot don't want to go more than half a molar less or more than, but this depends on ratio required.

Neil Wyatt 15/01/2018 16:55:24
avatar
Moderator
19124 forum posts
738 photos
81 articles

In practise pressure angle simply needs to be matched for each pair of gears, only it will look better if the whole railroad train share the aforementioned pressure level angle.

In practice older equipment/machines typically had fourteen.5 degree gears then Jason is probably correct that they will actually be more correct in advent.

Pressure angle does not change whatever gear calculations, except it affects when you need to make allowances for undercutting when making pinions with pocket-sized numbers of teeth (14.5 caste gears get undercut at 32 teeth, 20 caste at 17 teeth).

I'd gauge twenty DP is specced considering your pinion is 17 teeth. If you use a fourteen.5 degree cutter you can get around this by making the pinion slightly oversize (typically past virtually i/four of a molar depth) and either increasing the gear spacing or making the mating cycle undersize by the same amount and accepting 'squarer' teeth.

This works better with hobbed than form cut gears.

Neil

Martin Rock-Evans 15/01/2018 nineteen:36:l
26 forum posts
14 photos

Many thanks all for the advice and back up. Neil, I'm slightly confused past your comment most undercutting, if the tooth form requires undercutting, I'k guessing that tin't be washed by a disc shaped gear cutter?

Neil Wyatt 16/01/2018 12:52:42
avatar
Moderator
19124 forum posts
738 photos
81 manufactures

Posted by Martin Rock-Evans on fifteen/01/2018 19:36:50:

Many thanks all for the advice and support. Neil, I'chiliad slightly confused by your comment about undercutting, if the tooth class requires undercutting, I'chiliad guessing that can't be done by a disc shaped gear cutter?

No, it requires a hobbed or generated gear to make an undercut, just if you use a pitch circle shift you can cut a usable gear with a form cutter.

Neil

Michael Gilligan 17/01/2018 08:26:20
avatar
20827 forum posts
1129 photos

Martin,

A little exploration of this superb utility should evidence enlightening: **LINK**

http://hessmer.org/gears/InvoluteSpurGearBuilder.html

MichaelG.

Neil Wyatt 17/01/2018 10:45:39
avatar
Moderator
19124 forum posts
738 photos
81 articles

Posted by Michael Gilligan on 17/01/2018 08:26:20:

Martin,

A petty exploration of this superb utility should prove enlightening: **LINK**

http://hessmer.org/gears/InvoluteSpurGearBuilder.html

MichaelG.

That'due south generally what I use to create STLs for 3D printing.

Stephen Meredith 29/09/2019 10:54:26
avatar
10 forum posts
17 photos

Hi Martin, only quick question did you go with the

14.v deg PA ? im in the aforementioned boat thinking of building

the same model and price of the cutters.

RDG seem a price effective solution but only if the 14.5

worked out.

Stephen.

one-time mart 29/09/2019 16:xviii:02
4071 forum posts
270 photos

Cheers to that diagram, I now know what the departure is.

Martin Stone-Evans 29/09/2019 17:51:37
26 forum posts
fourteen photos

Howdy Stephen, I went for the specified 20 deg PA in the terminate. Steve Holder at sales@homeandworkshop.co.uk was able to supply the cutters I needed 2nd hand at a reasonable price.

Hither are some of the resulting gears:20190521_101833.jpg

2019-09-02 10.56.07.jpgHow-do-you-do Stephen, I went for the specified xx deg PA in the finish. Steve Holder at sales@homeandworkshop.co.great britain was able to supply the cutters I needed 2nd hand at a reasonable toll. Here are some of the resulting gears:2019-07-14 19.31.31.jpg 20190521_101833.jpg

Stephen Meredith 30/09/2019 xiii:44:34
avatar
10 forum posts
17 photos

Fantastic looking chore Martin, I feel reading the entire thread you did the correct thing, I volition try to follow the same.

Keep upward the good work, and keep posting I'm sure it helps lots of people, not but me.

Just ordered the first few bits from Bridport so now in committed.

Regards Stephen.

Stephen Meredith 01/11/2019 15:48:37
avatar
10 forum posts
17 photos

Cutters Obtained!

Just an update I concluded upwards going to the Midlands model engineering evidence and dropped lucky with the aforementioned Steve Holder. (Abode and workshop)

I bought 3 of the cutters needed to start cut gears for the engine at a reasonable price and all-important 20deg cutters. Really started machining the smokebox tube and a few castings purchased my other finished engine can be seen to the correct hiding one" Minnie. The new smokebox existence three times larger. smiley

Edited By Stephen Meredith on 01/11/2019 15:57:17

Stephen Meredith 06/12/2019 x:39:44
avatar
10 forum posts
17 photos

Ane final question martin.

What did you use for the rear axle,

Is obtaining the required length in silver steel the fashion

Or is a simple MS bar polished upward enough to run polish

In the bearings. I can imagine a ground bar being pricey especially as its longer than thirteen" the standard for silvery steel.

Whatever help appreciated from anyone.

Andrew Johnston 06/12/2019 10:55:54
avatar
6767 forum posts
701 photos

As per the cartoon I'thousand using 1-v/eight" bore EN8 for the rear beam on my iv" Burrell. The finish of the bar every bit drawn is fine as far as I'm concerned. Of course I'll remove any dings and burrs, merely as drawn information technology's probably better than the original. I dispensed with the bronze bearings in the terminal drive tube also. So it'south steel on cast iron.

Andrew

All Topics | Latest Posts

Delight login to post a reply.

20 Degree Pressure Angle Gears,

Source: https://www.model-engineer.co.uk/forums/postings.asp?th=133100

Posted by: silvavenind.blogspot.com

0 Response to "20 Degree Pressure Angle Gears"

Post a Comment

Iklan Atas Artikel

Iklan Tengah Artikel 1

Iklan Tengah Artikel 2

Iklan Bawah Artikel